SCOTUS To Rule On Colorado’s Exclusion Of Christian Preschools

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
The Supreme Court will hear arguments next week on whether Colorado can bar Catholic preschools from its universal program, marking the state's fourth First Amendment loss in a decade.

The Supreme Court will hear a major case next week to decide if Colorado can exclude Christian preschools from its state-funded program. This dispute centers on St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, where the state barred Catholic schools from receiving money for their universal preschool efforts. The justices will hear arguments on Tuesday regarding the state’s requirement that schools accept all families regardless of their beliefs. According to the Washington Examiner, over the past ten years, the Supreme Court has decided three First Amendment disputes against Colorado. This new case could become the fourth major loss for the state if the justices side with the Catholic plaintiffs.

Following the 2020 voter approval of a measure establishing a state-funded preschool program, this legal fight started. The legislature passed a law requiring participating schools to sign an agreement promising equal enrollment opportunities. This mandate includes a pledge to accept students without regard to religious affiliation or sexual orientation. A group of parents and Catholic parishes filed a lawsuit claiming the rule violates their First Amendment rights. They argue that the mandate forces them to act against their sincerely held religious beliefs. In June 2024, a federal district court dismissed the claims made by Catholic challengers, ruling in their disfavour. The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals also sided with Colorado in a September 2025 decision.

What the Lawyers Are Saying

Legal experts representing the Catholic schools argue that the state is trying to bypass Supreme Court protections. Amanda Dixon, who serves as counsel for the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, informed The Federalist that this situation exposes governmental efforts to sidestep settled rights. Dixon noted that while the court has said governments need a good reason to burden religion, Colorado keeps trying to outmaneuver those rules. She told the Washington Examiner that the state seems to ignore previous rulings against it.

Dixon added that Colorado lacks a strong track record at the high court but continues to act as if it has the right to exclude religious groups. Jim Campbell, chief legal counsel at the Alliance Defending Freedom, told the Washington Examiner that the state is no respecter of the First Amendment. He noted that his group has dealt with these cases against Colorado for more than a decade. The state previously lost cases involving a Christian baker, a web designer, and restrictions on therapist speech. Colorado officials have defended their actions by claiming they must ensure all children grow up safe and respected.

The Supreme Court will grapple with questions surrounding the First Amendment and longstanding precedents. Critics argue that a specific ruling has caused confusion in how courts handle religious exercise. However, the state of Colorado argues that its contract requirement exists in harmony with the Constitution. The appellate court found that the state’s rule does not violate the preschools’ rights. This decision was not challenged on appeal regarding the congregation preference clause.

State Attorney General Phil Weiser called previous losses a setback but vowed to continue standing up for care grounded in science. He framed the legal challenges as attacks on the rights of all children. The state’s defense relies on the idea that public funding comes with conditions that apply to everyone. Yet the Catholic plaintiffs insist that admitting families who do not share their teachings sacrifices their core beliefs. The outcome of this case will likely impact how other states handle similar universal programs. It marks the fourth time Colorado has faced the Supreme Court for alleged First Amendment violations in ten years. The justices must now decide if the state can lawfully exclude Catholics from the program.


Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Add New Playlist